Mill Creek Cafe in Honeoye

Locally owned and operated cafe with plenty of atmosphere with an amazing food and beer selection. The walls are full of interesting artwork, some of which is for sale. Dining can be done indoors or outdoors and there is a beautiful Creek by the parking lot and an ice cream store next door. It doesn't get any better than that.

Greek wrap is delicious

I love this place. Had panko fish fry for the first time! Perfect 💙🧡💜

A homey spot with great food and service

Awesome drinks and food! Can be busy on the weekends, but it’s worth the wait!!

Friendly and good food. Parking is tough and sometimes hard to find seating. Not necessarily a bad thing.

The food is great, the waiters are always smiling, overlooking a few here and there but this place is really good for a quick bite but also a big meal. A bit too cramped if you want to eat outside and the situation on the inside is similar but only if you bring a group. The place is clean, the food comes quick and I wholeheartedly recommend if you're ever in the area. A must visit.

Outstanding quality food. The employees are great and the patrons were too. Uncommon for all three anymore...

Always willing to work with me on getting my meal customized for Keto, fresh made and delish Everytime!

Small but cozy restaurant. Don't.let the "Cafe" in the name fool you! Top notch food with gourmet style and flavor! I had the " broth bowl" which was huge! I choose beef as my protein. Fresh, thin julianne sliced veggies in a huge bowl of beef broth with rice noodles. Poutine is on the menu and is also a HUGE portion!

Great atmosphere, great food. Staff is always a delight. Owner and his family are wonderful caring people, they just want to make sure you have a great time while you visit.

This place is great, will definitely be back.

This place is awesome. The food is creative, fresh and delicious! It is small but always bustling. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable. They often greet guests by name with a handshake or a hug. The atmosphere is surprising. The outside is very simple but the interior is full of beautiful sculptures and other artwork. The music is fun and relaxing. They have outdoor seating and live music in the warmer months. It is an unexpected gem in a small town. *they have the best gluten free, cauliflower pizza/flatbread crust ever!

Unique offerings, reasonable prices. My husband and I each had a different wrap style sandwich and fries. Very tasty! Service was great. Cute place.

Nice place to stop. Indoor seating or during summer outside seating under umbrellas. Service staff very pleasant and cordial. Had clam chowder and salad with shrimp. Excellent. Quick refills on my ice tea. Owner even came around to see if everything was ok. My favorite place to stop at when in the area. During summer, they have an ice cream, etc.

Enjoyed this quaint restaurant. Food was excellent! Best service and food in the finger lakes area! Look forward to a return visit next summer!

Mill Creek Cafe is definitely a hidden gem in Honeoye! You wouldn't believe that this tiny little shack beside a creek could serve such high quality food in such an inviting atmosphere. Great drink selection, amazing food, and a fantastic wait staff!!

The place is amazing and the food is very delicious. Very small, cute place with lots of options. Very friendly staff and if we are ever in the area again, would definitely come. I highly recommend this place.

Quietly hidden in honeyoe my, offering great food, great ice cream and great service! Highly recommended

Culinarily experts! Wow! Want something different with a nice atmosphere in the middle the beautiful fingerlakes? Try Mill creek.

What a pleasant surprise. we’re here on vacationAnd we’re just driving around looking for a coffee shop, discovered the Mill Creek. From the one the moment we walked in the front door we were welcomed with delicious smells, wonderful service, and a cozy environment.The prices were reasonable, food was delicious, service was exceptional.A real gem in the Honeoye Lake community.

Great place to eat. One of the best breakfasts I have ever had. Wonder what the dinners are like...time will tell.

My husband and I love this place wish we could take them back home with us. Their french onion soup is the best you will ever have.

Great food! Excellent service. This place has a little bit of everything for everyone to enjoy including an ice cream shop making homemade waffle cones. Food menu features farm fresh local ingredients we will be back! Of course the Stella was ice cold...great place!

An interesting choice of specials. The Greek pillar wrap was delicious and my wife had a salad with steak and blackened shrimp she was pleased. The service was very good and the live music by Red Means Go was great! Of course the ice cream shop is an added bonus. This place is worth checking out! l.

Waitress was friendly and attentive. My burger was good. My wife's wrap looked and tasted like hot vomit. She ate a single bite, and alerted the waitress that something was wrong. The chicken was unrecognizable as such, and the romaine lettuce looked and had the texture of cooked spinach. The waitress tried to make it right, but it took 20+ minutes for a substitute burger to be made. We could hear the kitchen complaining and about 5 minutes before the burger came out, a male employee who may or may not have been a manager (he never identified himself) decided to question why my wife didn't like her wrap in condescending, cheauvenistic manner. We left without taking delivery of the burger. The billing was fair (they did not charge us for the wrap or burger). That and the nice waitress are the only good things I can say.

Mill Creek is a must go to place if you are visiting the little Finger Lakes region. Ordered steak/chicken rice bowls and did not disappoint. Have also frequented their ice cream window as well. Looking forward to the days of live music there.

Had an Awesome breakfast here! Blueberry stuffed pancakes were So Yummy!Breakfast sandwich was fresh & not greasy like some places have! Excellent home fries!Our server was friendly & prompt. We will definitely be back!

The Blackened Surf-N-Turf Salad was absolute perfection! I can't recommend it enough.

Good food, nice atmosphere, very clean and cozy. Totally enjoyed our visit.

Great food! Wonderful service! Thanks Caleb!

Went on a Friday night and it was very busy. Once we were seated, they were very attentive. Fun atmosphere and very friendly. Had the steak quesadillas. It was very good. Also the bundt cake was a great end to the dinner. Would definitely recommend.

Phenomenal Food, Great Service and Atmosphere... Highly Recommend.... Definitely Would Go Again

This place is great. Cozy little sandwich place. Cool atmosphere with super friendly staff. The food was great. Had the Buffalo Chicken Flatbread and it was amazing. Will definitely be back.

I got their Buffalo chicken quesadilla. It was way better than I expected it to be. I would definitely go back.

This was my first time here, however my aunt and Grandmother come here often. This fish fry- both beer battered and panko, were delicious! The dinner portion was enough for 2 people or leftovers. The sweet potato fries, homemade tartar, and Woodstead sauce made this dish even better. I cannot wait to be back in the area to dine here again! ***Picture of my plate was after I had devoured most of it.

Tried for the first time on Saturday. Great food and service. French onion soup and poutine cant be missed. Worth a visit. Our favourite place around Honeoye lake.

Great food, friendly staff. Get the dessert

Absolutely the best place in town. All of the food was incredible and the service was fantastic.

Fun place to eat. Always had good meals.

Nice little restaurant that we may have caught on an off day. The service was very slow over an hour at lunch, seemed like management short staffed. It's good to see a chef using grass fed beef but it was way overcooked so hot it burned my tongue. My wife's rice bowl lacked a little bit in flavor but was good. With that being said we are going to give them another try.

Food was delicious. Caleb our server was very knowledgeable and attentative. Local craft beer on tap a plus

Very good food and excellent service!!!

Excellent quality food. Delish! Friendly and helpful staff. Great decor.

Great service. Great food.

This is our favorite casual restaurant. The menu is diverse and accommodates vegans, health-conscious and everything in between! Absolutely love the cauli-wings! It’s one of our favorite appetizers ever. The salads are amazing. My favorite is the surf & turf salad. You can’t go wrong with anything on the menu. The staff is friendly & atmosphere casual and family friendly.

Excellent food and great staff. Everything is fresh and many items are locally sourced ,which is nice. Really eclectic decorations on the inside are a fun change of pace from normal restaurant fixtures.

Great place to get ice cream out front on a hot summer day. Servings are very generous

Great service and amazing food options. Ordered the Black and Bleu wrap and freshly made lemonade.

Very unique, great food and service